Guide
APR vs interest rate vs APY
A loan advert can show three different percentages for the same money. Here is what each one counts, how lenders work them out, and which one to use when you compare offers.
By Mark Stoumann ·
The interest rate is what the lender charges on the balance you owe. The APR (annual percentage rate) adds the fees you pay to get the loan and turns the total into one yearly rate. The APY (annual percentage yield) is for savings: what your money earns in a year once interest on interest is counted. The short version: compare loans by APR and savings by APY, but check what the APR leaves out.
For guidance only, not financial advice. Real offers depend on fees, taxes and terms. Check the exact figures with your bank, lender or accountant before you decide.
The interest rate: the price of the money
The interest rate, sometimes called the nominal or stated rate, is the number lenders use to work out each month's interest. On a loan quoted at 7% a year with monthly payments, the lender charges 7 ÷ 12 = 0.5833% of the balance every month. That is exactly how MathyBit's loan calculator builds its repayment schedule.
What the interest rate doesn't show is anything else you pay to borrow. The US Consumer Financial Protection Bureau puts it plainly: the interest rate is the yearly cost of the money itself and leaves out fees and other charges. Two offers at the same rate can cost very different amounts.
APR: the interest rate plus the fees
The APR answers a better question: if all the compulsory costs of the loan were charged as interest, what would the rate be? To find it, lenders take the money you actually receive (the loan minus any fees taken at the start) and find the rate at which your payments add up to exactly that amount, in today's money. The fees count; optional extras you can refuse usually don't.
Worked example: you borrow 10,000 at 7% over 5 years. The monthly payment is 198.01, so you repay 11,880.72 in total. Now add a 300 arrangement fee, paid at the start. The payments stay the same, but you have only received 9,700 of usable money. The monthly rate that turns sixty payments of 198.01 into 9,700 is 0.6905%, which is where the APR comes from.
Why the same loan has a different APR in the US and the UK
Here is the part most explanations skip. The US and the UK (and the EU) turn that monthly rate into a yearly one in different ways.
- United States: under Regulation Z, the APR is the rate per period multiplied by the number of periods in a year. No compounding: 0.6905% × 12 = 8.29%.
- United Kingdom and EU: the UK's rules, which implement the EU Consumer Credit Directive, discount every payment by (1 + APR) raised to the time in years. That makes the APR an effective, compounded yearly rate: 1.006905¹² − 1 = 8.61%, shown to one decimal place as 8.6%.
The same three loans, side by side:
| 10,000 borrowed at 7% | Monthly payment | US-style APR | UK/EU-style APR |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 years, no fee | 198.01 | 7.00% | 7.2% |
| 5 years, 300 fee | 198.01 | 8.29% | 8.6% |
| 3 years, 300 fee | 308.77 | 9.07% | 9.5% |
Two lessons. First, a UK APR is higher than the stated rate even with no fees, because monthly interest compounds: 7% charged monthly is 7.23% over a full year. Second, the same fee pushes the APR up more on a shorter loan, because it is spread over fewer payments. The 3-year loan above still costs less in total (1,115.75 of interest plus the fee, against 1,880.72 plus the fee over 5 years), even though its APR is higher. When terms differ, compare the total amount repayable too.
Representative APR: the rate most people get
UK adverts usually say "representative APR". The FCA defines it as a rate the lender reasonably expects at least 51% of the people who take out credit through that advert to get, or better. The other 49% can be offered more, often depending on their credit history. So an advertised 6.9% APR tells you what a typical customer pays, not what you will pay. Only the personal quote you get after applying, or from a soft-search eligibility check, is your rate.
What the APR leaves out
The APR is the best single number for comparing loans, but it has blind spots:
- It assumes you keep the loan to the end. Fees are spread over the full term. If you repay a mortgage early or remortgage after five years, the upfront fees were spread over fewer years and cost you more per year than the APR suggests.
- It assumes variable rates stay where they are. On a variable or adjustable loan, the APR is worked out as if today's rate lasted the whole term.
- It leaves out optional and conditional costs. Late fees, early repayment charges and add-ons you can decline are not in it.
APY and AER: the same idea for savings
For savings, the question is the other way round: how much will my money earn? US banks must quote the APY, defined in the Truth in Savings rules (Regulation DD) as the interest earned in a year, with compounding, as a share of the deposit. The official formula takes the interest earned over the term and scales it to 365 days:
APY = 100 × ((1 + interest ÷ principal)^(365 ÷ days in term) − 1)
The regulation's own example: a six-month, 182-day deposit of 1,000 that earns 30.37 has an APY of 6.18%. UK banks quote the AER (annual equivalent rate) for the same purpose; unlike the gross rate, it includes compounding. Here is how often interest is added changes the yield on a 5% rate:
| 5% interest added | APY / AER | 10,000 after one year |
|---|---|---|
| Once a year | 5.000% | 10,500.00 |
| Quarterly | 5.095% | 10,509.45 |
| Monthly | 5.116% | 10,511.62 |
| Daily (365) | 5.127% | 10,512.67 |
The differences are small next to the rate itself. A savings account at 4.5% compounded daily still pays less than one at 5% compounded yearly. Our compound interest calculator lets you pick the compounding frequency, and the rule of 72 guide shows how those rates translate into years to double.
Which rate to use when
| You want to | Use |
|---|---|
| Work out a monthly payment | The interest rate |
| Compare loans of the same length | The APR |
| Compare loans of different lengths | APR and the total amount repayable |
| Compare savings accounts | APY or AER |
| Compare a US and a UK quote | Convert first: they compound differently |
Paying a loan down faster changes the picture again. Our guide to how much extra mortgage payments save works through the numbers.
Frequently asked questions
Is a lower APR always the better deal?
Usually, for loans of the same length. APR spreads the fees over the term, so it lets you compare offers with different fee and rate mixes. Be careful when the terms differ: a fee spread over 3 years pushes the APR up more than the same fee over 5 years, even though the longer loan may cost more in total. Compare the total amount repayable as well.
Why is my APR higher than my interest rate?
Because the APR includes charges you pay to get the loan, such as arrangement fees, broker fees or points, as if they were extra interest. In the UK and EU the APR also includes the effect of monthly compounding, so it is higher than the stated rate even with no fees at all.
Can the APR be lower than the interest rate?
Not with a normal loan. It can happen when a lender pays you something up front, such as cashback or a credit towards closing costs, because that lowers the effective cost of borrowing.
What does representative APR mean in a UK advert?
It is the rate the lender expects at least 51% of the people who take out credit through that advert to get, or better. Up to 49% can be offered a higher rate, so the APR in your own quote is the one that counts.
Is APY the same as AER?
They answer the same question for savings: how much you would earn in a year once compounding is counted. APY is the US term, set by the Truth in Savings rules, and AER is the term UK banks use.